Reviewed by
Families place enormous trust in assisted living facilities. When a loved one moves into a senior living community, the expectation is that the facility will provide the services, supervision, and care that were promised.
A class action lawsuit involving Brookdale Senior Living Inc. has raised questions about whether certain assisted living communities in Florida and North Carolina were adequately staffed to meet residents’ needs. The litigation has now resulted in a proposed class action settlement that may provide payments to certain current and former Brookdale residents.
The settlement does not mean that Brookdale admitted wrongdoing. Brookdale denies the allegations and liability, and the court has not ruled that Brookdale violated the law. Instead, the parties agreed to resolve the litigation through a settlement.
For residents and their families, the important questions are: What was the lawsuit about? Who may qualify? How much could eligible residents receive? And what must they do to participate?
A quick note: this class action does not consider individual injuries. If your loved one was wrongfully injured or died inside a Brookdale facility, contact Senior Justice Law Firm today to discuss your potential Brookdale negligence lawsuit.
What Is the Brookdale Class Action Lawsuit About?
The litigation, Bright v. Brookdale Senior Living, Inc., was brought on behalf of current and former residents of certain Brookdale assisted living facilities in Florida and North Carolina.
The plaintiffs alleged that Brookdale failed to provide staffing sufficient to meet residents’ needs. They also alleged that Brookdale made representations in marketing materials and residency agreements that led residents to believe its communities would be adequately staffed to provide the care for which residents were paying.
According to court records, the plaintiffs further alleged that Brookdale’s staffing practices were driven by predetermined labor budgets and profit goals rather than residents’ actual care requirements.
Those are allegations and not findings of fact.
Brookdale has denied wrongdoing and liability. The settlement resolves the claims without requiring the court to determine whether the plaintiffs’ allegations or Brookdale’s defenses would ultimately prevail.
Why Does Staffing Matter in Assisted Living?
Staffing is one of the most important considerations for families evaluating an assisted living or memory care community. Understaffed facilities are usually linked with more frequent injuries and bad resident outcomes.
Residents may depend on facility staff for assistance with activities such as bathing, dressing, medication management, mobility, meals, toileting, supervision, and other daily needs. The level of assistance required can differ substantially from one resident to another.
That is why allegations involving understaffing can be particularly significant in the assisted living setting. A facility may look impressive during a tour, but families ultimately depend on the people working inside that facility to provide the services their loved one needs.
The Brookdale litigation centered on the plaintiffs’ contention that residents paid for services with the understanding that staffing would be sufficient to meet those needs, while Brookdale disputes those allegations.
Who Is Included in the Brookdale Settlement?
Eligibility is more complicated than simply having lived at a Brookdale facility.
The settlement covers certain residents of Brookdale assisted living facilities in Florida and North Carolina, but the applicable dates and requirements differ depending on where and when the resident lived and whether a community fee was paid.
North Carolina Residents
The settlement potentially includes people who moved into a Brookdale assisted living facility in North Carolina:
- From April 24, 2016 through May 13, 2026, if they paid a community fee; or
- From September 23, 2014 through May 13, 2026, if they did not pay a community fee.
Florida Residents
The settlement potentially includes people who moved into a Brookdale assisted living facility in Florida:
- From November 10, 2019 through May 13, 2026, if they paid a community fee.
There is also a separate category for certain Florida residents who moved into a Brookdale facility between May 3, 2015 and November 9, 2019. Those residents may potentially qualify if they either opted out of an earlier Brookdale class action settlement known as Runton v. Brookdale Senior Living Inc. or submitted a claim in that settlement that was denied by the settlement administrator.
Florida residents who did not pay a community fee are not included in the settlement.
But these residency requirements are only part of the eligibility analysis.
The Arbitration Requirement Is Critical
One of the more unusual, and potentially confusing, aspects of the Brookdale settlement concerns arbitration agreements.
To qualify for the settlement class, the resident’s contractual documents must indicate that there is no enforceable arbitration agreement for one of the reasons specified by the settlement.
That may be the case where a residency agreement was signed by another person on the resident’s behalf, but the document authorizing that person to act excluded the authority to consent to arbitration or waive the resident’s right to a jury trial.
A resident may also qualify where the arbitration provision in the residency agreement was crossed out or otherwise declined in writing.
Conversely, a resident generally is not included if the resident or an authorized representative signed a residency agreement containing an arbitration provision without striking or declining it, assuming the representative had the relevant authority.
This issue is important because arbitration agreements played a significant role during the underlying litigation. In one 2023 ruling, for example, the federal court denied Brookdale’s attempt to compel arbitration as to a Florida resident where the power of attorney expressly withheld the agent’s authority to waive a jury trial.
For families trying to determine whether a former Brookdale resident qualifies, the admission paperwork, residency agreement, power of attorney, and any documents addressing arbitration may therefore be especially important.
How Much Money Could Settlement Class Members Receive?
The amount depends primarily on whether the resident paid a community fee.
Under the settlement, eligible class members who paid a community fee may receive:
26% of the community fee they paid, plus $50 for each year they lived at a Brookdale assisted living facility, for up to three years.
For example, suppose an eligible resident paid a $3,000 community fee and lived at the facility for three years. Twenty-six percent of $3,000 is $780. The additional residency payment could be $150, resulting in a potential settlement payment of $930, assuming the claim is approved and the settlement terms apply as expected.
Eligible North Carolina residents who did not pay a community fee are entitled to $255, regardless of how many years they lived at the Brookdale facility.
Do Eligible Residents Automatically Receive Money?
No. A claim must be submitted to receive a settlement payment.
According to the official settlement website, eligible class members can submit a claim electronically or mail a completed claim form to the settlement administrator.
Online claims must be submitted by 11:59 p.m. Eastern Time on January 24, 2027. Claims sent by regular mail must be postmarked no later than January 24, 2027.
The settlement administrator will review claims and may reject a claim if it determines that the claimant is not a member of the settlement class.
What If the Brookdale Resident Has Died?
Many assisted living claims involve former residents who have since passed away. That does not necessarily mean the potential settlement claim disappears.
The settlement provides a separate claim form for an authorized representative. Depending on the circumstances, an estate representative or another legally authorized individual may therefore be able to pursue a claim for a deceased resident.
Families in this situation should pay close attention to what documentation is required to establish their authority to act for the former resident.
What Are the Important Settlement Deadlines?
The court granted preliminary approval of the settlement on May 13, 2026.
The current settlement schedule lists several important dates:
- September 10, 2026: Deadline to object to the settlement.
- September 10, 2026: Deadline to request exclusion, or “opt out,” from the settlement.
- October 26, 2026 at 2:30 p.m. Central Time: Final approval hearing.
- January 24, 2027: Deadline to submit a claim.
These deadlines involve very different rights.
Submitting a claim generally means participating in the settlement and seeking the payment available to an eligible class member.
Opting out means asking to be excluded from the settlement. That decision can be significant because remaining in a class settlement generally involves releasing covered claims, while exclusion may preserve a person’s ability to pursue those claims separately.
An objection is different from an opt-out request. A class member who objects is telling the court that he or she disagrees with some aspect of the proposed settlement.
Residents and families should read the official settlement notice carefully before deciding which option is appropriate for their circumstances.
Why Families Should Review Their Brookdale Records
One lesson from this settlement is that assisted living admission paperwork can have consequences years after it is signed.
Families may want to locate and preserve documents including:
- The resident’s admission or residency agreement;
- Any arbitration agreement or arbitration provision;
- Documents showing that arbitration was declined or crossed out;
- Powers of attorney or other documents authorizing someone to sign for the resident;
- Records showing payment of a community or entrance fee;
- Billing statements and payment records; and
- Documents showing when the resident entered and left the facility.
These records may help determine whether a resident falls within the settlement class and what payment may be available.
Does Senior Justice Law Firm Handle Brookdale Class Action Claims?
Should I Investigate an Injury Claim Before Opting Into the Class Action?
No, our firm does not handle this specific class action claim against Brookdale.
However, Senior Justice Law Firm has filed numerous individual injury lawsuits against Brookdale, for injuries ranging from resident falls, bed sores, untreated infection and wrongful death.
These individual injury claims usually settle for far more than the amounts listed above for the class action. This is why, if you think you may have an individual injury claim against Brookdale, you should explore that claim before signing a release and settling a case as part of a class action.
If your loved one was injured or died potentially due to negligence at Brookdale, it is crucial that you have an assisted living negligence attorney review your case facts before opting into the class action class. Contact Senior Justice Law Firm today for a completely free case consultation: 888-375-9998.
Talk to an Assisted Living Attorney About Your Rights
The Brookdale settlement may provide compensation to certain residents in Florida and North Carolina, but determining eligibility can require more than checking the name of the facility and the dates of residency.
- Community fees, arbitration provisions, powers of attorney, prior participation in the Runton settlement, and other documents may all affect whether a resident qualifies for the Brookdale Class Action settlement.
- Further, if there is a viable assisted living negligence claim, families should investigate that claim before waiving their legal rights by opting into a class action.
Families who received a Brookdale settlement notice should review it carefully and pay particular attention to the September 10, 2026 opt-out and objection deadline and the January 24, 2027 claim deadline.
Families who believe a loved one suffered an injury because an assisted living facility failed to provide appropriate care should speak with an attorney about whether they have claims separate from the settlement. For these claims, contact Senior Justice Law Firm today for a free negligence case consultation at (888) 375-9998.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. The settlement remains subject to final court approval, and settlement terms, deadlines, and procedures should be confirmed through the official settlement materials.
Legal Nurse Consultant
